Page:The Journal of geology (IA journalofgeology11893univers).pdf/137

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
ORIGIN OF MOUNTAIN RANGES.
563

by tension. But there would inevitably come a time when the surface being substantially cool and moreover receiving heat also from the sun, its temperature would be fixed or nearly so, while the incandescent interior would be still cooling and contracting. Such has probably been the case ever since the commencement of the recorded history of the earth. The hot interior now cooling and contracting more rapidly than the cool crust, the latter following down the ever shrinking nucleus would be thrust upon itself by lateral pressure with a force which is simply irresistible. If the crust were ten times, yea one hundred times more rigid than it is, it must yield. It does yield along the lines of greatest weakness, i. e., along marginal sea-bottoms as already explained. As a first attempt at a physical theory, it seems reasonable, and therefore, until recently, has been generally accepted.

OBJECTIONS TO THE CONTRACTIONAL THEORY.

It is well known that American geologists have taken a very prominent part in the study of mountain structure and mountain origin. So much so indeed that the lateral pressure theory in the form given above and interior contraction as its cause, have sometimes been called the "American theory." It is also well known that my name, among others, especially Dana's, has been associated with this view. All I claim is to have put the whole subject, especially the formal theory, in a clearer light and more consistent form.[1] The formal theory I regard as a permanent acquisition. The contractional theory may not be so. It is natural, from my long association with it, that I should be reluctant to give it up. But I am sure that I am willing to do so if a better can be offered. We all dearly love our own intellectual children, especially if born of much labor and thought; but I am sure that I am willing, like Jephtha of old, to sacrifice, if need be, this my fairest daughter on the sacred altar of Truth. Objections have recently come thick and fast from many directions. Some of these

  1. "Theory of the Formation of the Great Features of the Earth's Surface."Am. Journal, Vol. 4, pp. 345 and 460, 1872, and also "Structure and Origin of Mountains,"Vol. 16, p. 95, 1878.